Cache Valley League was an Independent League
1914 Cache Junction Ut, Hyde Park Id, Lewiston Id, Logan Ut, Mendon Ut, Preston Id, Richmond Ut, Smithfield Ut, Wellsville, Ut
1919 Lewiston Ut, Logan Ut, Preston, Id, Richmond, Ut, Smithfield Ut, Wellsville, UT
1920 No Teams enter the league or left the league.
1923 Clarkston Ut, Lewiston Ut, Logan Ut, Preston Id, Smithfield, Ut Wellsville, UT
1926 Cornish Ut, Franklin Id, Lewiston Ut, Preston Id, Richmond Id, Weston Id
1927 Preston Id enter the League and Corrnish has left the league
1928 Cache Junction Ut, Clarkston Ut, and Logan Ut enter the league and Preston left the league