| Year
| Player, Team
|
| 1949 | Joe Page (RP), New York Yankees
|
| 1950
| Jerry Coleman, New York Yankees
|
| 1951
| Phil Rizzuto, New York Yankees
|
| 1952
| Johnny Mize, New York Yankees
|
| 1953
| Billy Martin, New York Yankees
|
| 1954
| Dusty Rhodes, New York Giants
|
| 1955
| Johnny Podres (P), Brooklyn Dodgers
|
| 1956
| Don Larsen (P), New York Yankees
|
| 1957
| Lew Burdette (P), Milwaukee Braves
|
| 1958
| Elston Howard, New York Yankees
|
| 1959
| Larry Sherry (RP), Los Angeles Dodgers
|
| 1960
| Bill Mazeroski, Pittsburgh Pirates
|
| 1961
| Whitey Ford (P), New York Yankees
|
| 1962
| Ralph Terry (P), New York Yankees
|
| 1963
| Sandy Koufax (P)(1), Los Angeles Dodgers
|
| 1964
| Bob Gibson (P), St. Louis Cardinals
|
| 1965
| Sandy Koufax (P)(2), Los Angeles Dodgers
|
| 1966
| Frank Robinson, Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1967
| Lou Brock, St. Louis Cardinals
|
| 1968
| Mickey Lolich (P) Detroit Tigers
|
| 1969
| Al Weis, New York Mets
|
| 1970
| Brooks Robinson, Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1971
| Roberto Clemente, Pittsburgh Pirates
|
| 1972
| Gene Tenace, Oakland Athletics
|
| 1973
| Bert Campaneris, Oakland Athletics
|
| 1974
| Dick Green, Oakland Athletics
|
| 1975
| Luis Tiant (P), Boston Red Sox
|
| 1976
| Johnny Bench, Cincinnati Reds
|
| 1977
| Reggie Jackson, New York Yankees
|
| 1978
| Bucky Dent, New York Yankees
|
| 1979
| Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh Pirates
|
| 1980
| Tug McGraw (RP), Philadelphia Phillies
|
| 1981
| Ron Cey, Los Angeles Dodgers
|
| 1982
| Bruce Sutter (RP), St. Louis Cardinals
|
| 1983
| Rick Dempsey, Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1984
| Jack Morris (P)(1), Detroit Tigers
|
| 1985
| Bret Saberhagen (P), Kansas City Royals
|
| 1986
| Ray Knight, New York Mets
|
| 1987
| Frank Viola, Minnesota Twins
|
| 1988
| Orel Hershiser (P), Los Angeles Dodgers
|
| 1989
| Dave Stewart (P), Oakland Athletics
|
| 1990
| Billy Hatcher, Cincinnati Reds
|
| 1991
| Jack Morris (P) (2), Minnesota Twins
|
| 1992
| Dave Winfield, Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 1993
| Paul Molitor, Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 1994
| None awarded; Series cancelled due to strike
|
| 1995
| Tom Glavine (P), Atlanta Braves
|
| 1996
| Cecil Fielder, New York Yankees
|
| 1997
| Moises Alou, Florida Marlins
|
| 1998
| Scott Brosius, New York Yankees
|
| 1999
| Mariano Rivera (RP), New York Yankees
|
| 2000
| Derek Jeter, New York Yankees
|
| 2001
| Randy Johnson (P), and Curt Schilling (P), Arizona Diamondbacks
|
| 2002
| David Eckstein, Anaheim Angels
|
